From this North American Ed-Tech magazine:
Dr. Mark Carrigan is a digital sociologist at the Manchester Institute for Education, where he leads the master’s degree in digital education. He has spoken out about the question of whether it’s time for academics to let go of Twitter.
He said Twitter had a significant impact on the culture of academia, including the broadening of academic networks and leveling of academic hierarchies, which is why he finds its recent instability so concerning.
“I’m convinced the site is going to die because of the debt burden and business model collapsing,” he said.
Because of that conviction, he’s encouraging fellow academics who have become habitual users of it to face the fact that it’s in terminal decline and to consider whether it continues to be beneficial to spend time and effort on it. Part of the issue, he noted, is the disparity of experiences between non-subscribers and subscribers.
“Unless an academic is willing to pay the subscription fee, their experience of Twitter is going to get progressively worse,” warned Carrigan. “And their ability to be seen and heard on Twitter is going to decrease over time. It’s not a very appealing prospect.”
LinkedIn has been gaining traction as an X alternative for academics, he said, but that the norms of it are quite different and can feel constraining. “I don’t think there’s going to be just one Twitter alternative because we’re entering a very fragmented landscape,” he stressed.
